Matt killed Mitch and stole his identity – Sienna ripped off the skin mask and panicked Y&R Spoilers

SPOILER SUMMARY – “Matt Killed Mitch and Stole His Identity – Sienna Ripped Off the Skin Mask and Panicked | Y&R Spoilers”

In “Matt Killed Mitch and Stole His Identity – Sienna Ripped Off the Skin Mask and Panicked,” The Young and the Restless delivers one of its darkest and most jaw-dropping storylines yet — a chilling mix of murder, deception, and psychological manipulation that leaves viewers questioning everything they thought they knew about the newest mystery in Genoa City.

The episode begins with what seems like a normal morning at Newman Media. Sienna arrives early, uneasy but determined to keep her professional life from collapsing under the weight of the strange events that have been unfolding. Ever since Mitch’s sudden “return” from overseas, nothing has felt right. His behavior — the subtle differences in how he speaks, the way he moves, even the way he looks at her — has filled her with a sense of dread she can’t explain.

“Maybe I’m just overthinking,” Sienna mutters to herself, staring at a framed photo of the man she once trusted completely. But deep down, she knows — this isn’t the Mitch she knew.

As the episode unfolds, the cracks in “Mitch’s” façade begin to show. He avoids old friends, stumbles when asked about past memories, and grows visibly angry whenever someone mentions his time away. Victor, always the observer, begins to sense something off and quietly asks Adam to dig into Mitch’s background. That decision sets off a chain of revelations that will shatter Genoa City.

Meanwhile, Sienna can’t shake her unease. Late one evening, she sneaks into Mitch’s office, determined to find proof of whatever he’s hiding. As she rifles through his files, she discovers a locked drawer containing a fake passport — not for Mitch, but for a man named Matt Callahan. The photo is unmistakable: it’s the same face as Mitch’s. Her blood runs cold.

Before she can process what it means, she hears footsteps behind her. “Looking for something?” a voice says. She turns to see “Mitch” — or rather, Matt — standing in the doorway, his expression chillingly calm. “You shouldn’t have done that, Sienna.”

The tension in the room is unbearable. She demands to know who he really is. His voice hardens. “Mitch is gone,” he says flatly. “He wasn’t supposed to find out what I was doing. He forced my hand.”

Her horror is instant. “What did you do to him?” she whispers. Matt smirks, stepping closer. “Let’s just say Mitch won’t be coming back. But don’t worry, Sienna — I’ve taken good care of his life. Better than he ever did.”

Sienna’s mind races as the truth hits her: Matt killed Mitch and has been living under his identity. But the full horror hasn’t even been revealed yet. In one of the most chilling scenes The Young and the Restless has ever delivered, Sienna lashes out, grabbing at his face during the struggle — and to her horror, the skin peels away. Beneath the surface, a grotesque, artificial mask comes loose, revealing Matt’s real features underneath.